[Buddha-l] Re: Buddhist social deconstruction

[Steven Rhodes]

Dear Bernie,

I believe that this discussion is in The Precious Garland (vv. 330-337), 
not in The Friendly Letter.

Best wishes,

Steve


Bernie Simon wrote:

> Since we're on the subject of prison, I recall that Nagarjuna had 
> something to say about the subject in his Letter to a Friend. I find 
> this text valuable because it's one of the few that I know of that 
> speak about the political and social implications of Buddhism. Perhaps 
> some of the list members know of some other texts.
>
> http://www.ecst.csuchico.edu/~dsantina/friend.htm
>
> Nagarjuna does not neglect even the case of offenders against the law, 
> common criminals.  Even those who deserve punishment because of their 
> ill deeds should be treated with compassion.   Compassion should in 
> fact be generated even towards those who have committed awful crimes.  
> Murderers in particular should be objects of compassion for those who 
> are of a virtuous nature.
>
> Nagarjuna went so far as to concern himself with the treatment of 
> prisoners.  He recommends that the weaker prisoners be freed after a 
> single day or at the most five days of imprisonment.  Indeed, one 
> should never think of imprisoning anyone for life].  In fact, the 
> simple thought of imprisoning someone for life is a cause of breaking 
> the Buddhist layman's Commitment to protect life.
>
> Conditions in the prisons too do not escape Nagarjuna's attention.  He 
> says that as long as prisoners are not freed, they should be made 
> comfortable.  They should be provided with barbers, baths, food, drink 
> and medicine.  Finally, Nagarjuna expresses a concept that only dawned 
> upon western social philosophers at the time of the eighteenth century 
> so called "enlightenment" in Europe.  That is, wrong doers should be 
> punished with the sole wish to reform them, not with the wish to exact 
> revenge or retribution.  Like sons who have gone astray, prisoners 
> should be punished in such a way as to make them once again worthy 
> members of society.
>
> ----
> Bernie Simon / Jinpa Zangpo
>
> _______________________________________________
> buddha-l mailing list
> buddha-l at mailman.swcp.com
> http://mailman.swcp.com/mailman/listinfo/buddha-l
>