[Buddha-l] Another query
StormyTet at aol.com
StormyTet at aol.com
Fri Jul 22 18:50:03 MDT 2005
Hi All,
I am just beginning the process of digesting the modernist/postmodernist
debates. It seems to me that there is some similarities between postmodern
thought and Buddhism. Has this ever been a topic of scholarly discussion in
Buddhist academic circles? Any suggestions where to look?
For example, In "Postmodernism and Social Inquiry" edited by David Dickens
and Andrea Fontana, the author David Ashley, speaks in less-than-glowing terms
of "Baudrillard's rejection of [...] reason immanent in modernism [as having]
more in common with Hindu or Tao mysticism than with Western philosophical
traditions" (Ashley 1994, p 61).
Also, in an article by Fredric Jameson in "New Left Review" v. 146 p. 53-92,
Jameson says the following using Munch's 'Scream" as an example of the
postmodern condition :
"...Expression requires the category of the individual monad, but it also
shows us the heavy price to be paid for that precondition, dramatizing the
unhappy paradox that when you constitute your individual subjectivity as a self
sufficient field and a closed realm in its own right, you thereby also shut
yourself off from everything else and condemn yourself to the windless solitude
of the monad, buried alive and condemned to a prison cell without egress."
Jameson believes that the postmodern condition has fragmented the
individual, whereas more radical postmodern thinkers believe that there never really
was an individual and that the postmodern age has just revealed the truth of
our ephemeral ego nature. What I find interesting about Jameson here is that I
think it would be considered doctrinally correct to say, from a Buddhist pov,
that there is only One Life or one Self that Is (condemned or not)? Of
course, Jameson is talking about the individual ego here, but I have also read
Buddhist's who suggest that the dance of Maya was began in the first place
because 'nobody likes to eat alone," so to speak.
Does anybody have any suggestions as to readings or comments in re. to these
ideas?
Thanks
Stormy Tetreau
"
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://mailman.swcp.com/mailman/private/buddha-l/attachments/20050722/36267ee1/attachment.htm
More information about the buddha-l
mailing list